The looming DNA test that will inevitably identify him as being a killer. Smyth gets down to business by slowly revealing to Williams what police have found out about the murders of Jessica Lloyd and Cpl. Cal Miller and Ian Robertson, How a Colonel Became a Killer (2011). He did not know why he had targeted Marie-France from amongst all of her colleagues on the base and purposefully used his status as base commander to specifically access her personal information. Our dealership here in Ottawa says theyre very popular for the Pathfinder, so. Jim Smith interrogated the killer for six hours before handing the interview over to Det. On the night of 2. Williams had pleaded guilty to all 88 charges against him. Williams looked insulted, then exhaled deeply, grinned wide, and shook his head. Williams raped her and made her pose for photographs. Often the suspect is asked to provide sketches of crime scenes or draft letters of apology to his victims. Then Williams took Lloyd to his silver-coloured 2001 Nissan Pathfinder, parked in a nearby field, and drove her to his cottage. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. Frustrated by their inability to find Jessicas body, they recruited the help of Williams himself. Williamss head continued to bob in a rapid succession of gentle nods, his forehead growing increasingly flush from the stress he was under. Detective-Sergeant Smyth provided him with a pad of paper and a pen and suggested that he write some letters of apology to his victims, another common tactic used by police to avoid later allegations of a false confession. To Roxanne Lloyd, the mother of twenty-seven-year-old murder victim Jessica Lloyd: You wont believe me, I know, but I am sorry for having taken your daughter from you. ), Monterey Park, CA Police Department FBINA 214th Session Member - International Association of Chiefs of Police, Police Investigative Operations Committee Email: Jim.Smith@ecoatm.com It's at this point where Williams "is absorbing everything that's just been said to him and that's for the first time that he knows that he's caught," Perry said. . Victims outraged about staging of Russell Williams confession | CBC News Loaded. Williams vehemently denied being aware of such an order, and became defensive at the suggestion that it had been given by someone under his command. Upon returning to the base later that night, he had driven straight back to his home in Ottawa to spend a couple of days with his wife. . "This type of thing is designed to overcome the will of any person, and it may be good, it may be useful at getting confessions from people who are guilty," said defence lawyer James Foord. Dafoe, who has a photo of Lloyd in her bedroom, said Smyth reached out to her after he saw her online petition and until then she hadn't thought about the investigator. None of Williamss Tweed victims reported break-ins to the police. On March 21, the jury watched avideotape of a May 2009 police interviewinwhich Ontario Provincial Police Det. Smyth was not the only police officer to be criticized in the ruling. This time when the officer returned, Williams had written a total of five apology letters (and three discarded drafts). . Police found tire tracks whose distinctive tread narrowed the range of potential suspect vehicles to a few, including the Nissan Pathfinder. In 2006, he completed the Canadian Police College polygraph examiner's course, resulting in his certification as a forensic polygraph examiner and forensic interviewer. Coincidentally, perhaps, Cary Road was often used by the colonels next-door neighbor to reach his secluded hunting camp. Theyd be able to find her easily there, Williams assured him. The trial into the death of Victoria Stafford has revealed disturbing details about the final hours of the Woodstock, Ont., girl, but it has also shed light on a highly skilled police interrogator. Director Adam Seelig cast two women playing the parts of Smythand Williams alternating between the roles, and they'llbe joined by a drummer on stage to fillin censored gaps of the transcript. Marie-France made a lasting impact in Trenton, and will be sorely missed by her many friends. . But thepsychologist isso bothered by the 90-production, scheduled to run March 3-12, she has decided to hand out pamphlets to theatre-goers on opening night tonight to remind them of the victims. The detective explained how DNA profiling had advanced so much that only a tiny sample was now required to determine a match. They look for a way to open up a suspect and to get them to start talking. "Let's be clear, this play has not been'written.' One does not need a diploma in psychology to understand that a person with the psychological and mental impairments [that Mr. Armishaw has] is a uniquely vulnerable individual when confronted with a vastly more clever interrogator who is in a position of authority in relation to him, Judge Langdon wrote. He then elaborated on the difference between and interview and an interrogation and the techniques used. "He just thought he was going to outsmart everybody else and talk his way right out of it," Mendelson told CTV Toronto after viewing the video of the confession. I know she loved you very much. He was an avid photographer, and he stored and categorized all of his digital photos in his office on individual memory keys, with each key assigned to its own cardboard box and clear plastic baggy. She was enraged about the staged reading of the murderer's confession to OPP officer Jim Smyth and started a petition to stop the play, which about 2,000 people signed. That evidence is all there. . He challenged the colonel as to why he did not use his swipe card on Tuesday, November 24, 2009 (the day following Comeaus murder), despite the fact that it was used every other day that week at the base. . Some werent aware at the time that their homes had been violated, or hadnt noticed anything missing. As the detective told him that investigators were applying for a warrant to search his office at the military base, Williams sat upright and sighed, his earlier confidence clearly diminished. . Im just trying to understand, like, why her versus, you know, the dozens of other women youve probably come across on a daily basis?. I dont see that in you. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. He could also smell a slight odour of decomposition, he said. In the Williams interview, it became clear that his relationship with his wife was very important, which Smyth keyed into when he offered him the chance to minimize the impact on his spouse. Captured on video, they're seated in a small room, each with a chair. . [He then stopped writing and scribbled out the lines he had written.]. rights reserved. "It was an excellent piece of police work on behalf of Jim Smyth who conducted this interview one of the best interviews I've ever seen," Det. Then he was asked about Comeau and the circumstances of his first murder. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation experts want to know from Ontario Provincial Police Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth? Because this is, this is getting out of control really fast, Russell. I was in Gatineau, as I said, meeting about the C-17., Okay, now if that is the day you had a meeting in Ottawa, do you remember being at the base on the Monday the twenty third and swiping your card in and out? Smyth periodically left the interrogation room to get updates from the search teams, which provided him with more damning facts. . there is a warrant being executed at your residence in Ottawa, okay? Well, I think I killed her because I knew her story would be recognized. He feared that the ritualistic behavior of having his victims pose for explicit photographs would have caused the crimes to be linked together. Harriman, who claimed to have known nothing about her husbands crimes, began divorce proceedings. Follow live updates from the courtroom as Globe reporter Timothy Appleby covers the plea and sentencing hearing of Colonel Russell Williams. If this didnt come to the point its at right now. Provincial Court Judge Mike Dinkel excluded the confession, concluding she told Calgary police what they wanted to hear. The few people who were close with Col. Williams have said Curio's death, which took place around the 2008 Christmas holidays, had a profound and visible impact. Investigators from the OPP and the Belleville Police Department suspected that the sexual assaults in Tweed, the Comeau murder and Lloyds disappearance were connected. Call me Russ, please. His congenial tone finally indicated a readiness to move forward. Close to a minute of stark silence passed as Williams sat stock-still. Marie-France Comeau, along with 86 other charges. In fact, much like TVs Columbo, he probably owed much of his success to peoples innate tendencies to underestimate his talents and resolve. This website uses cookies to personalize your content (including ads), and allows us to analyze our traffic. Essentially [it] has become more and more precise to the point where, when you and I walked in this room earlier today, we couldve sat down, talked for thirty seconds, walked out. [2] Instead, the interviewer would strive to appear confident yet relaxed, and at least as calm as the suspect.[3]. Butts, E. (2016). The colonel raised his head, rubbed his neck, and looked his interrogator straight in the eyes. Jim Smyth questions Terri-Lynne McClintic about her involvement in Stafford's death. The most effective seems to have been his use of false evidence to convince Mr. Armishaw that he was guilty.. He was educated at Upper Canada College and the University of Toronto. "I moved one rock aside. OPP Det. Later they moved to a home they had built in the capitals Westboro neighbourhood. Skilled in Government, Law Enforcement, Emergency Management, Conflict Resolution, and Presentation. What do you need?, Well, do you want to supply things like fingerprints, blood samples. Chief Instructor at Integrity Interviewing for Investigators Greater Toronto Area, Canada 974 followers 500+ connections Join to follow Integrity Interviewing for Investigators. Thats a little microphone.. After the detective had deftly planted the seed in the mind of his now-rattled opponent, he excused himself from the room for a break. In June 1997 he began working with the OPP, moving to the behavioural sciences section of the force in 2000. In effect, the 100-page analysis of Det.-Sgt. Get email updates from your favourite authors. consistent with a Pathfinder. And finally, to Ernie Comeau, the father of thirty-eight-year-old murder victim Marie-France Comeau: I am sorry for having taken your daughter, Marie-France, from you. To assist police in their grim task of finding the girl's remains, McClintic had drawn a sketch of the area where she said she and boyfriend Michael Rafferty left the body. After another long pause, Williams sighed. McClintic said at the time that Rafferty had killed Tori using a hammer, but at trial she testified it was her. Everything about the interrogation is crafted down to specific details about how the officer acts and requires a lot of preparation in advance, Downs said. When we find out whos responsible for one or all of those crimes, they could be charged. Over the next 10 hours, Williams gave a detailed confession around Lloyd, but also Corporal Marie-Frances Comeau and at least two other cases initially.The Behavior Panel is a group made up of the world's top body language and behavior experts, Mark Bowden, Scott Rouse, Greg Hartley, and Chase Hughes. After Jaydin died, from brain injuries consistent with shaking, police also interrogated Kayla, but failed to pursue inconsistencies in her evidence, Judge Langdon wrote. Williams was decorated for his years of exemplary service and for a tour of duty in the Middle East. It was soft," Smyth testified. Absent any other solid evidence against him, Mr. Armishaw was acquitted and the prosecution abandoned as having no reasonable prospect of success. Absolutely not, he said, re-crossing his arms and shifting himself forward in his seat. It is a priority for CBC to create products that are accessible to all in Canada including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges. Some of the memory cards were simply stowed in a camera bag, while others were tucked away in a desk drawer in his office. I wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt, but you and I both know you were at Jessica Lloyds house, and I need to know why.. But sensing that relinquishing control would be a difficult step for the career military man who had been trained to remain tough and withstand intense interrogation tactics by enemy forces, he offered the colonel a concession. [np-related]In his written reasons, Judge Langdons criticism of Det.-Sgt. Col. Williams also revealed to police in the interrogation that he suffered from chronic pain, a condition that his co-workers and old friends have returned to time and time again when they've been asked by reporters about any changes they observed. At the time, he had murdered two young women by suffocation, beaten and tied up two of his neighbours before photographing them naked, and stolen about 500 items of lingerie and clothing from the closets of unsuspecting women. Williams asphyxiated Comeau by wrapping her face with duct tape. to colleagues, clients or customers, or inquire about Rafferty has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, sexual assault causing bodily harm and kidnapping. He suspects Williams would have weighed the judicial process that lay ahead when making his decision to confess. Williams often spent time at a cottage he owned on Cosy Cove Lane in the village of Tweed, Ontario, 53 kilometers from Trenton. Soon after, Williams tells Smyth to get a map. permissions/licensing, please go to: www.TorontoStarReprints.com. Smith pleaded guilty to a charge of falsely concealing his alleged affair with Katrina Leung, from the FBI. Williamss next victim was Jessica Lloyd. Like, is it something where I can make a call and tell somebody to go to a location. Unlike his interviewers seat, his chair was without wheelsa standard police protocol. Colonel David Russell Williams was a decoratedair forcepilot and commander at theCanadian Forces Base(CFB) atTrenton,Ontario, when he was arrested in 2010, and charged with the murders of two women, and numerous other sexually related crimes. He writes that Det.-Sgt. On the night of 89 September 2007, Williams broke into a neighbours cottage while the family was away, and took photographs of himself in pornographic poses with a young girls underwear, some of which he stole. That's what you're going through right now," Smyth is seen telling McClintic. "We have one of the best justice systems in the world. Let me ask you this, Smyth continued. Signing up enhances your TCE experience with the ability to save items to your personal reading list, and access the interactive map. I spent 10 years on the road, 3 of which I was on the Emergency Response Unit. Committed to his decision, the colonel offered to draw diagrams for the officer showing exactly where he had hidden memory cards and two hard drives full of evidence at his Ottawa homehoping that police would then be less intrusive with their search efforts. I prefer Law & Order, but I do watch CSIoccasionally, Williams said. He mentions it on two or three occasions," said a source close to the investigation who has reviewed Col. William's detailed statement to police. Brenda McGillvray. All We apologize, but this video has failed to load. Major successes include his work on the interrogation of Michael Briere, who confessed to killing 10-year-old Holly Jones in Toronto in 2003, and his profiling in the case of Tori Stafford, 9, which led him to discover the girls remains by following a hunch to a rural field. The video begins with Smyth telling Williams why he has been called in to speak with police. In those cases, conventional wisdom dictates that the interrogator should say little or nothing while the suspect stews. Use of this Website assumes acceptance of Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy | Accessibility, Published Friday, October 22, 2010 2:16PM EDT, Last Updated Saturday, May 19, 2012 3:00AM EDT, Taxpayers pick up cost of damage to Williams' home, Williams evidence should be destroyed, lawyer warns, After Williams trial, residents hold 'healing event', 'Sadosexual' killer Williams gets 2 life sentences, From the Archives: Fans celebrate Leafs 2004 playoff win, This globetrotter raises $300,000 for kids with disabilities, What you need to know about faded, peeling Ontario plates, CTV National News for Apr. I was a Military Police Officer for 3 years prior to joining the OPP in 1993. Read more about cookies here. Today we are once again reminded of the selfless sacrifices the brave men and women in uniform make. Smyth said in the interrogation. On February 7, Williams was interrogated by OPP investigator Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth and confronted with the evidence of tire tracks and boot prints at Lloyd's home. You know theres only one option. He realized that there would be significant consequences for his actions, so his decision had to be a calculated and informed one. Also available from Amazon, With the purpose of writing about true crime in an authoritative, fact-based manner, veteran journalists J. J. Maloney and J. Patrick OConnor launched Crime Magazine in November of 1998. The colonel nodded and continued to chew his gum. He served the FBI from October 1970 to November 2000 and specialized in Chinese counterintelligence. . He really didnt understand himself any better than the detective did. And now, just like his four bound and helpless victims, there was nothing the air force colonel could do to escape his fate. However, the confession contradicts McClintic's claims at the ongoing trial of Rafferty that she was the one who dealt the fatal blows to the eight-year-old girl. Smyth lied to Mr. Armishaw about the evidence against him; engaged in a relentless monologue at a suspect who wished to remain silent; undermined Mr. Armishaws lawyers advice by suggesting the lawyer was ignorant of the overwhelming evidence against him; claimed to speak for the courts, and offered leniency in exchange for a confession; and placed a false choice before Mr. Armishaw confess or be damned in which innocence, though still technically presumed, was not an option. The bizarre case shocked the military and the country and became an international media sensation. The director calls it a documentary on stage. Recovering alcoholic and divorced father of a young daughter, DS Jim Bergerac is a true maverick who prefers doing things his own way, and consequently doesn't always carry out his investigations the way his boss would like. . Dafoe grew up with the 27-year-old Belleville resident, who was killed in 2010 by the former commander of CFB Trenton in eastern Ontario. As you can see here, everything in this room is videotaped and audiotaped, Smyth said, drawing the colonels attention to three mounted cameras that were recording their meeting from different angles. In both cases the victims called the police, but only after the Massicotte attack did the OPP advise the public. Williams was married to Mary Elizabeth Harriman. When youre dealing with footwear impressions, we have a gentleman on the OPP whos basically world-renowned. Aside from this action, Dafoe like other friends and family of victims tries to stay out of the public discourse, worried that talking about it might intrigue people to attend. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Thanks for contributing to The Canadian Encyclopedia. Ontario Provincial Police ~ Peterborough Detachment. . "It's a smart man, outsmarted by a smarter man," OPP Det. "They begin circling in and in and in it was a fascinating thing to watch," said CBC reporter Dave Seglins. After several minutes of backpedaling, the detective managed to salvage the interview and refocus on the aspects that had been breaking the colonels resolve. Like the victims' loved ones, Smyth and the OPP decline interviews, in part because of the healing process. Interviews are conducted one-on-one, so there is no real or perceived ganging up to intimidate the suspect. Creator Robert Banks Stewart Stars John Nettles Terence Alexander Sean Arnold See production, box office & company info Smyth was recently promoted to the OPP's major criminal investigations branch as a major case manager. The detectives conversational-style questioning flip-flopped around with little apparent focus, often seeming to lack any specific direction or structure. They were settled with undisclosed financial payments in 2014. southend council garages to rent, john henton and kim coles,
Which Is A Reason For Using Good Hygiene Practices?,
Articles D